Friday, September 4, 2009

No word on tax leniency


Photo by: Thun Sophea
Motorists call for a 50 percent reduction in motorcycle taxes in Poipet last week.


The Phnom Penh Post
Friday, 04 September 2009
May Titthara

Motorists say the government hasn't clarified any plan to reduce penalties for unlicenced, undutied vehicles.

MOTORISTS who gathered last week in provinces around the country to protest fines for unlicensed vehicles, enforced as part of the Land Traffic Law, are still awaiting resolution of their grievances by government authorities.

On August 12, Prime Minister Hun Sen said in a speech at the graduation ceremony for Phnom Penh's Royal University of Law and Economics that traffic police and customs officers should begin imposing fines on those who had not paid import taxes or lacked licencing for their vehicles.

Under Article 79 of the Land Traffic Law, drivers of unregistered vehicles that lack licence plates may be subject to fines from 25,000 to 200,000 riels (US$6 to $48).

After thousands of people gathered last week in Siem Reap, Banteay Meanchey, Preah Sihanouk and Battambang provinces, provincial authorities in these areas suspended fine collection and vehicle confiscation indefinitely, saying that they would consider a reduction in fine levels.

In the week since, however, those who protested have yet to hear any more on the matter from provincial officials.

"The police stopped fining us temporarily, but we are still waiting for a definite result before we pay the import taxes," said Phan Lavorn, a representative of protesters in Banteay Meanchey province.

Vor Vorn, a 31-year-old motorbike taxi driver from Siem Reap province who claimed to be a representative of the protesters there, said that drivers in his province would resume their demonstrations against the fees if the government does not provide them with a resolution by the end of this week.

"We really want to get a resolution so that we can go about our work with confidence," he said. "The government should help us by not delaying any longer ."

Sam Dy, a motorbike taxi driver from Preah Sihanouk province, said drivers there would also renew their protest if they do not hear from government officials soon. "Now we feel like thieves because we can't do our work without breaking the law," he said.

Meas Vuthy, deputy governor of Preah Sihanouk province, did not anticipate further problems in his province. "We have followed instructions from the General Department of Customs and Excise, as we are not fining the drivers for lacking licence plates, though they still have to pay the import tax," he said Thursday. All 117 motorbikes confiscated for lacking licence plates in his province have been returned, he added.

Pen Siman, director of the General Customs and Excise Department at the Ministry of Economy, could not be reach for comment Thursday. Nor could provincials officials from Siem Reap and Banteay Meanchey.

Tuol Sambo community decries vote


The Phnom Penh Post
Friday, 04 September 2009
May Titthara

VILLAGERS at the Tuol Sambo resettlement site, which is home to more than 60 HIV-positive individuals, are locked in a dispute with City Hall and the community's former chief over the appointment of a new leader after a vote Wednesday.

Residents say City Hall put forward five candidates from the community, but Khum Khoeun, chief of Tuol Sambo village, proposed a sixth - Sao Vanna - former chief of the community before its relocation from Borei Keila.

Khum Khoeun said he included Sao Vanna - named the new chief with 48 out of 62 votes - after Sao Vanna complained about not being a candidate to City Hall, which ultimately sided with him.

Suon Davy, another resident of the Tuol Sambo community, charged Sao Vanna with bringing others who live in Borei Keila to the new community to unfairly influence the vote. "Sao Vanna caused many problems for us during his leadership of the community while it was at Borei Keila," Suon Davy said, adding that he showed interest in the community only recently after NGOs and government officials had visited the site and offered donations.

Sao Vanna could not be reached comment Thursday.

Civil parties start boycott of KR tribunal


Photo by: AFP
Khmer Rouge survivor and Cambodian civil party Nam Mon points to a photo of her brother, a victim of the Khmer Rouge, Monday at the Tuol Sleng genocide museum.


The Phnom Penh Post
Friday, 04 September 2009
Chean Sokha and Robbie Corey-Boulet

THE Khmer Rouge tribunal lost some familiar faces this week as a group of civil parties - some of whom had been attending almost daily - launched a boycott protesting a decision they said unfairly restricted their participation.

The Trial Chamber last week ruled that civil party lawyers would not be allowed to question character witnesses, prompting criticism that judges were reneging on their promise to allow for "enhanced recognition of victims" in proceedings, which is billed on the tribunal's Web site as one of its "major innovations".

During a press conference Monday, 28 civil parties complained that the tribunal was weighing the interests of Tuol Sleng prison chief Kaing Guek Eav, alias Duch, over their own. An open letter to Trial Chamber President Nil Nonn listed examples of this "unbalanced" treatment, including the fact that Duch has been able to respond to all civil party testimony. Civil party Chum Sirath said Monday that the group would boycott until the chamber reconsidered its decision.

Court spokesman Reach Sambath said Thursday that the Trial Chamber had given no indication as to when it would explain the decision.

Civil party lawyer Kong Pisey said Thursday the decision was indefensible, adding that he had been hoping to ask questions about Duch's thinking and motives that had not been covered in earlier testimony.

Asked to provide an example, he said: "Duch converted to Christianity, so we want to ask him whether he thinks that cleared him of all the crimes he has committed."

Chum Mey, 79, a civil party who has attended nearly every day of the proceedings, also said he wanted to ask more questions about Duch's motives.

Nil Nonn this week repeatedly stonewalled efforts by civil party lawyers to raise the issue in court.

On Tuesday, for instance, civil party lawyer Alain Werner requested to read the open letter out for the judges. That request - along with three separate attempts by lawyers to explain to witnesses why the civil parties were not present - was denied, and by the end of the day Nil Nonn seemed to have grown tired of entertaining them.

"Alain Werner, you seem to have made the repetitive statement," he said. "We are not repetitious on this matter, and we will not allow you to raise this matter again."

The decision has effectively been finalised for the Duch trial. According to a press release issued Thursday, victim participation will be discussed during next week's plenary session, though only with respect to the court's second case. Civil party lawyers could file an appeal with the Supreme
Court Chamber, but this would not be processed before character testimony in the Duch trial concludes.

Long Panhavuth, a monitor for the Cambodia Justice Initiative, said Thursday that the dispute over civil party participation reflected widespread confusion about what their role should be.

UN court spokesman Lars Olsen said he did not believe there had been much confusion, though he noted that the system was new and thus led to "new experiences every day".

He said there is "always a balance between the rights of the accused and the rights of the victims", though he noted that "there is no other court in the world that has granted civil parties rights to the extent that this court has".

He added: "The court will welcome back the civil parties to attend the proceedings anytime."